Milburn Review's call to delay AE reforms risks leaving another generation ‘behind’

The Milburn Review into young people that are not in education, employment, or training (NEET) has called for proposed reforms to auto-enrolment (AE) to be delayed until 2031 at the earliest, but industry professionals have warned this risks leaving another generation behind in building retirement security.

In the review, report author and former Health Secretary, Alan Milburn, noted that the previous government had passed legislation that would enable the reduction of the lower age limit from 22 to 18 and the removal of the lower earnings limit.

While these reforms are yet to be enacted as the Pensions Commission continues its review of the pension system, Milburn argued the uncertainty mattered to smaller businesses, where relatively small employment cost increases can impact whether a young person is recruited.

He warned that implementing the changes while youth unemployment was under pressure would add another cost at a point when the UK needed employers to create more first jobs.

Therefore, Milburn recommended that reducing the AE age to 18 and removing the lower earnings limit for under-25s should not be enacted until 2031 at the earliest.

“The objective is not to create a permanently cheaper class of young worker, but to avoid loading new costs onto the first rung faster than the youth labour market can absorb them,” he stated.

However, Society of Pension Professionals president, Calum Cooper, warned that not reforming AE until 2031 risked leaving another generation of young people behind in building their retirement income.

“We are pleased that the Milburn review explicitly acknowledges that in relation to AE, reducing the lower earnings limit and the minimum age for eligible workers ‘have merit’,” he continued.

“We also recognise the concerns highlighted by the Milburn Review about the pressures facing employers, particularly SMEs, and the importance of protecting opportunities for young people entering the labour market.

“However, we should be seeking to support young people into their first jobs while also helping them build financial security for their later lives. These objectives should go hand in hand, rather than being considered as competing priorities.

“There is a legitimate debate about how best to manage the additional costs facing employers but postponing AE improvements until 2031 risks leaving another generation of young people behind in building their financial security for retirement.”



Share Story:

Recent Stories


Exploring the role of real assets
Pensions Age Editor-in-Chief, Francesca Fabrizi, joins Nuveen Real Assets Head of Strategic Insights, Abigail Dean, to explore the role real assets can potentially play in pension fund portfolios

AI and the future of UK pensions
Laura Blows speaks to Scottish Widows’ pensions expert Robert Cochran, about the growing role of artificial intelligence (AI) in the UK pensions industry

Supporting retirement decisions
Laura Blows discusses retirement saving levels in the UK, and the support required for members, trustees and employers, with WEALTH at Work director, Jonathan Watts-Lay

Pension risk transfer partnership
Podcast: From pension pot to flexible income for life

Advertisement Advertisement